The Best Options in 2026 - Tested by Experts
Our team spent thousands of hours researching and testing to bring you this definitive ranking. Updated monthly.
Quick Comparison
| Rank | Provider | Rating | Pricing | Best For | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | GAF Master Elite Contractors Editor's Choice | 4.8 | From ~$8,500 for full replacement | Excellent | Visit Site → |
| #2 | Owens Corning Preferred Contractors Best Materials | 4.7 | From ~$8,000 for full replacement | Excellent | Visit Site → |
| #3 | CertainTeed SELECT Contractors Best Premium Options | 4.6 | From ~$8,200 for full replacement | Excellent | Visit Site → |
| #4 | Standing Seam Metal Roofing Best Metal Roofing | 4.5 | From ~$15,000 for full replacement | Very Good | Visit Site → |
| #5 | Storm Damage Specialists Best for Storm Damage | 4.3 | Often covered by insurance (minus deductible) | Very Good | Visit Site → |
| #6 | Budget Roof Replacement | 4 | From ~$5,500 for full replacement | Good | Visit Site → |
Detailed Reviews
GAF Master Elite Contractors
GAF is North America's largest roofing manufacturer, and their Master Elite contractor network represents the top 2% of roofers in the country. Master Elite certification requires proven licensing, insurance, reputation, and ongoing training. Choosing a GAF Master Elite contractor gives you access to the strongest warranties available in residential roofing.
Pros
- +Strongest warranty in residential roofing - Golden Pledge covers workmanship for 25 years
- +Master Elite certification ensures licensing, insurance, and proven track record
- +Timberline HDZ shingles offer excellent wind resistance and curb appeal
- +Largest manufacturer means best parts availability and support
Cons
- −Master Elite contractors may charge 10-20% more than non-certified roofers
- −Not all areas have Master Elite contractors nearby
- −GAF shingles, while excellent, are mid-to-premium priced
Owens Corning Preferred Contractors
Owens Corning manufactures some of the highest-rated shingles in the industry, and their Preferred Contractor network ensures quality installation. Their Duration series shingles feature patented SureNail Technology for superior wind resistance, and the Total Protection Roofing System approach means every component works together.
Pros
- +SureNail Technology provides the strongest shingle-to-roof bond in the market
- +Total Protection system ensures all roofing components work together properly
- +Excellent color variety for matching any home style
- +Strong Preferred Contractor network with training requirements
Cons
- −Platinum Preferred warranty (their best) requires more specific product purchases
- −Slightly fewer Preferred Contractors than GAF Master Elite in some areas
- −Premium shingle lines are priced higher than GAF equivalents
CertainTeed SELECT Contractors
CertainTeed offers the widest range of premium roofing products, from luxury designer shingles that replicate slate and cedar shake to high-performance architectural shingles. Their SELECT ShingleMaster contractors undergo rigorous training and provide enhanced warranty coverage.
Pros
- +Best selection of luxury designer shingles for high-end homes
- +SureStart Plus warranty provides the most comprehensive early-year coverage
- +Landmark Pro and Presidential lines offer exceptional curb appeal
- +Strong contractor training and certification program
Cons
- −Premium designer shingles are significantly more expensive than standard architectural
- −Fewer certified contractors than GAF in some regions
- −Standard warranty terms are comparable to competitors but don't stand out
Standing Seam Metal Roofing
Standing seam metal roofing is the longest-lasting residential roofing option, with lifespans of 40-70 years - two to three times longer than asphalt shingles. The higher upfront cost is offset by decades of maintenance-free performance, superior storm resistance, and energy efficiency.
Pros
- +Longest lifespan of any residential roofing material - often the last roof you'll need
- +Excellent wind, hail, and fire resistance for maximum storm protection
- +Energy efficiency reduces cooling costs by 10-25% in warm climates
- +Environmentally friendly - 100% recyclable at end of life
Cons
- −Upfront cost is 2-3x higher than asphalt shingles
- −Fewer qualified installers - metal roofing requires specialized skills
- −Rain noise can be louder without proper insulation and underlayment
Storm Damage Specialists
After a storm, you need a roofer who understands the insurance claims process as well as they understand roofing. The best storm damage specialists work directly with your insurance adjuster, document all damage thoroughly, and ensure you receive the full settlement you're entitled to - without the storm-chasing scams.
Pros
- +Expertise in insurance claims maximizes your settlement amount
- +Proper damage documentation prevents underpayment by insurance companies
- +Emergency response prevents secondary water damage
- +Many offer to meet with the adjuster on-site for accurate assessment
Cons
- −Storm-chasing companies give the specialty a bad reputation - vetting is critical
- −Some charge supplemental fees not covered by insurance
- −Quality varies widely - ask for local references and verify licensing
Budget Roof Replacement
For homeowners on a tight budget or preparing a home for sale, a quality budget roof replacement using 3-tab or basic architectural shingles provides reliable protection at the lowest cost. The key is choosing a licensed, insured contractor who doesn't cut corners on underlayment, flashing, and ventilation.
Pros
- +Lowest upfront cost for full roof replacement
- +3-tab shingles still provide reliable 20-year protection
- +Good option for pre-sale renovations where ROI matters most
- +Widely available - every licensed roofer can install basic shingles
Cons
- −Shorter lifespan than premium materials
- −3-tab shingles have lower wind resistance (60-70 mph vs 110-130 mph)
- −Less curb appeal than architectural or designer shingles
How We Rank & Review
Our rankings are the result of a rigorous, multi-step evaluation process. We start with extensive market research to identify every viable option, then narrow the field based on reputation, customer feedback, and feature sets.
Each product on our list undergoes hands-on testing by our expert reviewers. We evaluate ease of setup, day-to-day usability, feature quality, customer support responsiveness, and overall value for money.
We also survey real customers to understand long-term satisfaction and reliability. Our ratings combine expert scores with customer sentiment to give you a complete, balanced picture.
We update these rankings monthly as new products launch, prices change, and we gather more data. Our goal is to always give you the most current, accurate recommendations possible.